Failure to qualify for the Champions League would cause Mesut Ozil and Alexis Sanchez to leave Arsenal, making the club also-rans for years, according to Paul Merson.
Merson also believes under-pressure manager Arsene Wenger "looks lost" in his role for the first time since taking charge over 20 years ago.
Arsenal are on the brink of crashing out of the Champions League at the last 16 stage for a seventh straight season having lost the first leg 5-1 to Bayern Munich at the Allianz Arena.
The fourth-placed Gunners also face a fight to return to the competition, with Liverpool and Manchester United close behind them in the Premier League table.
If Arsenal fail to make the top four, Merson predicts it would take his former club years to recover.
"If they don't finish in the top four this season, they will just be an also-ran club for a few years," he said to Sky Sports.
"Sanchez will go and I don't see Ozil staying there. They have a lot of players who have been there a long time.
"If they don't finish in the top four I don't see a world-class player going to play for Arsenal next season.
"If that doesn't happen, how are they going to get in the top four next season? Man City will buy again, Man United will buy again, Chelsea will buy again.
"Maybe Tottenham won't because of their new stadium but Liverpool will buy again. All of a sudden Arsenal get left behind."
Merson thinks Wenger is as vulnerable as he has ever been at Arsenal, but wants the players to take their fair share of the blame.
He continued: "I know it's been same old, same old for the last three or four years, but the other night [at Bayern] was the first time I have seen him look lost.
"Even in the press conference, he went in with the thought that he was in trouble. That is the first time I have really seen him like that. Usually he is quite confident and he will get out of it by saying the right words.
"Sometimes you have to draw a line, though. He takes all the stick and I'm one of those people that is probably on his back as much as anybody else.
"But these players are letting him down. He puts a team out and puts a lot of faith in these players who have been there for a long time - not like a year or two - these players have been at the club four, five and six years. Some even longer.
"They are not performing. They are letting him down and they keep on getting away with it."
|Don´t worry about Messi renewal, Valverde tells Barcelona fans|
|Cheika disrespected referee - Jones|
|´Griezmann? We´ll see´ – Valverde won´t rule out Barcelona pursuit of Atletico star|
|Cardinals & Larry Fitzgerald agree to 2018 contract extension|
|Uncapped Enever replaces injured Coleman for Twickenham clash|
|Goffin overcomes slow start & Thiem to set up Federer semi|
|Unsworth surprised to see Allardyce snub Everton|
|Six-week stadium ban for Sale boss Diamond|
|Mourinho has ´immense respect´ for Benitez|
|Howe backs Defoe to make World Cup squad|
|Everton speculation out of my control - Silva focusing on Hornets|
|Conte concerned by Manchester City´s breakaway lead|
|Man City results ´perfect´, but Guardiola demands improvement|
|David Luiz back in Chelsea squad, Conte confirms|
|Recovered Klopp offers Liverpool fitness update|
|Guardiola confident Aguero in ´perfect´ condition despite hospital trip|
|Ibrahimovic, Pogba and Rojo back for Manchester United|
|Fleetwood and Rose look set for desert duel, Fitzpatrick leads in Dubai|
|Heynckes compiling list of potential successors|
|Modric & Carvajal fit for Madrid derby|
|Bayern begin talks over Wagner deal|
|Pulis angered as Chadli sidelined for ´foreseeable future´|
|Neymar to join Ronaldo at Real Madrid? Zidane speaks out on PSG star|
|Edinburgh banking on Barclay after signing Scotland captain|
|Guardiola & Sane complete Man City award double|
|Five-try Holmes makes history as Kangaroos batter Samoa|
|Brave Chapecoense secure top-flight status|
|Mooney seals Australia Women´s Ashes victory|
|Tottenham have overtaken Arsenal as north London´s best - Sherwood|
|Brisbane Roar 3 Melbourne City 1: Papadopoulos at the double as hosts finally win|
|Seaman: Wenger must start Lacazette against Tottenham|
|I am more than just a goal machine - Ronaldo ignores Real Madrid criticism|
|Pujara shows resistance on another rain-affected day|
|Skriniar not interested in Barcelona speculation|
|France need Benzema, says Aulas|
|Warne: Australia look confused ahead of Ashes|
|Donald recovering after being hospitalised with chest pains|
|Youngs braced for ´confrontational and confident´ Wallabies|
|The Breakdown: A statistical look at Saturday´s rugby internationals|
|Van Dijk could leave Southampton in January|
|Sanchez snubbed Barcelona switch - Osorio|
|Malan posts century as England impress in Townsville|
|Atletico Madrid v Real Madrid: Simeone and Zidane face dangerous, defining Derbi|
|Aubameyang baffled by Dortmund suspension|
|Harden scores 48 points as Rockets soar|
|George, Hauritz and Tendulkar – Ashes surprise Paine´s last Test|
|He´s a class player - Hussey approves of Marsh recall for Ashes|
|Brown stars as Steelers crush Titans|
|Smith backs ´terrific´ Paine ahead of Ashes|
|Celtics claim 14th straight victory with comeback win over Warriors|
|WATCH: Brown makes incredible helmet catch for Steelers|
|´Surprised´ Paine thought Test career was over|
|Steelers QB Roethlisberger reaches new career milestones|
|Pochettino lauds Wenger longevity as he eyes 20 years at Spurs|
|Ronaldo: Real Madrid don´t fear PSG|
|Australia´s Paine pick an amazing Ashes gamble|
|Bancroft demanded Ashes spot, others were mediocre – Hohns|
|Zenit´s Mancini not thinking about Italy job|
|Altuve, Stanton named MVPs|
|Wenger advises Pochettino to fight the ´fear´ of winning trophies|
|Kirk leads RSM Classic after fine 63|
|Red Wings defenseman Witkowski handed 10-game ban after brawl|
|Broad backs Root to reach ´another level´ during Ashes|
|Sock sees off Zverev for semi-final spot|
|Ronaldo: I want seven Ballons d´Or... and seven children!|
|Paine gets shock Australia call for Ashes|
|Howedes ready for long-awaited Juventus debut|
|Bayern´s Wagner interest confirmed by Nagelsmann|
|Sherman targets comeback in May or June|
|Taylor replaces Coles for All Blacks at Murrayfield|